ABSTRACTS OF THE COMMUNICATIONS
PRESENTED AT THE XTH INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON TRANSFER
FACTOR, HELD IN BOLOGNA (ITALY) JUNE 22-24, 1995.
FULL REPORTS ARE PUBLISHED IN: BIOTHERAPY, VOL. 9, 1996.
FOREWORD:
TRANSFER FACTOR IN THE ERA OF AIDS
TRANSFER FACTOR - CURRENT STATUS AND FUTURE PROSPECTS
H. Sherwood Lawrence and William Borkowsky
Infectious Disease and Immunology Division, Departments
of Medicine and Pediatrics, New York University Medical Center,
550 First Avenue, New York, NY 10016, USA
We have detected new clues to the composition and function of "Transfer
Factor" using the direct Leucocyte Migration Inhibition (LMI)
test as an in vitro assay of Dialysates of Leucocyte Extracts (DLE).
This approach has revealed two opposing antigen-specific activities
to be present in the same >3500 <12,000 DA dialysis fraction
- one activity is possessed of Inducer/Helper function (Inducer
Factor). The opposing activity is possessed of Suppressor function
(Suppressor Factor). When non-immune leucocyte populations are
cultured with Inducer Factor they acquire the capacity to respond
to specific antigen and inhibition of migration occurs. This conversion
to reactivity is antigen-specific and dose-dependent. When immune
leucocyte populations are cultured with Suppressor Factor, their
response to specific antigen is blocked and Inhibition of Migration
is prevented.
****
TRANSFER FACTOR IN THE AGE OF MOLECULAR BIOLOGY
- A REVIEW
John M. Dwyer
The Division of Clinical Immunobiology of the Prince
Henry and Prince of Wales Hospitals of the University of New South
Wales, Sydney, 2031, Australia
Current data suggests that the transferring of immunologically
specific information by transfer factor molecules requires interaction
with a cell that has been genetically programmed to be antigen
reactive but at the time of interaction is unprimed. Contact with
transfer factor molecules would allow a naive recipient, on a first
encounter with antigen, to make a secondary rather than a primary
immunological response. Transfer factor molecules for each and
every antigenic determinant are thus necessary. Transfer factors
made from animals or humans are capable of transferring antigen
specificity across a species barrier. Even primitive species have
cells from which one can make transfer factors. The molecules are,
therefore, well conserved and it is reasonable to suggest that
they are important for normal immunological functioning. Proposed
mechanisms of action must explain the fact that transfer factors
obtained from the cells of high responder animals are capable of
transferring delayed hypersensitivity to low responder animals
while the reverse is not true. Transfer factor molecules are likely
to interact with the variable regions of the alpha and/or beta
chain of T cell receptors to change their avidity and affinity
for antigen in a way that otherwise would only occur after an encounter
with antigen.
****
ACTIVITIES AND CHARACTERISTICS OF TRANSFER FACTORS
Charles H. Kirkpatrick
Innovative Therapeutics, Inc., Denver, CO, USA
This report summarizes three components of our transfer factor
research program. Several clinical studies have used oral administration
of transfer factor containing materials. Sceptics have rejected
these findings by assuming that the acidic and enzymatic environment
of the gastrointestinal tract would destroy the factors. To further
examine this issue, we have conducted dose-response studies of
the delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction in mice that were given
transfer factor either by gavage or subcutaneously. There was no
difference in the responses that were related to the route of administration.
We conclude that oral route of administration is efficacious and
should be used when possible. We have also studied the effects
of transfer factors on immune responses by recipients. The details
of this research are presented in the paper by Dr. Alvarez-Thull.
Briefly, the study showed that recipients of a specific transfer
factor responded to the antigen for which the factor was specific
by secreting gamma-IFN, but no other cytokines. The structures
of transfer factor molecules are unknown. We have developed a process
for isolating transfer factors in pure form and we have obtained
preliminary data concerning amino acid sequences. Our goal is to
obtain the complete primary structure of several transfer factor
molecules.
****
AIDS AND TRANSFER FACTOR: MYTHS, CERTAINTIES AND REALITIES
Dimitri Viza
Laboratoire d'Immunobiologie, URA 1294 CNRS, Faculté de
Médecine, Paris, France
At the end of the 20th century, the triumph of biology is as indisputable
as that of physics was at the end of the 19th century, and so is
the might of the inductive thought. Virtually all diseases
have been seemingly conquered and HIV, the cause of AIDS, has been
fully described ten years after the onset of the epidemic. However,
the triumph of biological science is far from being complete. The
toll of several diseases, such as cancer, continues to rise and
the pathogenesis of AIDS remains elusive.
In the realm of inductive science, the dominant paradigm can seldom
be challenged in a frontal attack, especially when it is apparently
successful, and only what Kuhn calls "scientific revolutions" can
overthrow it. Thus, it is hardly surprising that the concept
of transfer factor is considered with contempt and the existence
of the moiety improbable: over forty years after the introduction
of the concept, not only its molecular structure remains unknown,
but also its putative mode of action contravenes dogmas of both
immunology and molecular biology. And when facts challenge established
dogmas, be in religion, philosophy or science, they must be suppressed. Thus,
results of heterodox research become henceforth nisi - i.e., valid
unless cause is shown for rescinding them, because they challenge
the prevalent paradigm. However, when observations pertain
to lethal disorders, their suppression in the name of dogmas may
become criminal. Because of the failure of medical science
to manage the AIDS pandemic, transfer factor, which has been successfully
used for treating or preventing viral infections, may today overcome
a priori prejudice and rejection more swiftly. In science,
as in life, certainties always end up by dying and Copernicus'
vision by replacing that of Ptolemy.
****
RATIONALE AND CLINICAL RESULTS OF USING LEUCOCYTE-DERIVED
IMMUNOSUPPORTIVE THERAPIES IN HIV DISEASE
A.A. Gottlieb, R.C. Sizemore, M.S. Gottlieb & C.H.
Kern
Tulane University, 1430 Tulane Avenue, New Orleans,
LA 70112; Imreg, Inc. 144 Elk Place Suite 1400, New Orleans, LA
70112
Leucocyte dialysates contain a number of substances which exert
important effects on human cell-mediated immunity. In this report,
we describe several properties of a designated subfraction, IMREG(R)-1,
which is obtained by a second dialysis against a membrane having
a 3500 m.w. cutoff. These include the ability to augment and accelerate
reactions of delayed hypersensitivity against antigens to which
the text subject has been previously sensitized, and the ability
to enhance the expression in vitro on CD4 lymphocytes of the p55
subunit of the receptor for Interleukin-2. We also report our observation
that in a patient with advanced HIV disease whose lymphocytes had
lost there ability to properly express the IL-2 receptor, treatment
with IMREG(R)-1 over a period of months restored the expression
of the IL-2 receptor on the patient's CD4+ lymphocytes towards
normal.
****
PRELIMINARY OBSERVATIONS USING HIV-SPECIFIC TRANSFER
FACTOR IN AIDS
Giancarlo Pizza(1), Francesco Chiodo(2), Vincenzo Colangeli(2),
Francesco Gritti(3), Enzo Raise(3), Hugh H. Fudenberg(4), Caterina
De Vinci(1) & Dimitri Viza(5).
(1)Immunodiagnosis and Immunotherapy Unit, 1st Division
of Urology, Ospedale S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, Italy; (2)Institute
of Infectious Diseases, Ospedale S. Orsola-Malpighi, Bologna, Italy;
(3)Dept. of Infectious Diseases and Immunopathology Unit, Ospedale
Maggiore, Bologna, Italy; (4)Neuro ImmunoTherapeutics Found. Spartanburg,
SC, USA; (5)Laboratoire d'Immunobiologie, URA 1294 CNRS, Faculté de
Médecine des Saints-Pères, Paris, France
Twenty five HIV-1-infected patients, at various stages (CDC II,
III and IV) were treated orally with HIV-1-specific transfer factor
(TF) for periods varying from 60 to 1870 days. All patients were
receiving antiviral treatments in association with TF. The number
of lymphocytes, CD4 and CD8 subsets were followed and showed no
statistically significant variations. In 11/25 patients the number
of lymphocytes increased, whilst in 11/25 decreased; similarly
an increase of the CD4 lymphocytes was observed in 11/25 patients
and of the CD8 lymphocytes in 15/25. Clinical improvement or a
stabilized clinical condition was noticed in 20/25 patients, whilst
a deterioration was seen in 5/25. In 12/14 anergic patients, daily
TF administration restored delayed type hypersensitivity to recall
antigens within 60 days. These preliminary observations suggest
that oral HIV-specific TF administration, in association with antiviral
drugs, is well tolerated and seems beneficial to AIDS patients,
thus warranting further investigation.
****
PRELIMINARY RESULTS IN HIV-1-INFECTED PATIENTS TREATED
WITH TRANSFER FACTOR (TF) AND ZIDOVUDINE (ZDV)
Enzo Raise(1), Luca Guerra(1), Dimitri Viza(2), Giancarlo Pizza(3),
Caterina De Vinci(3), Maria Luisa Schiattone(1), Leonarda Rocaccio(1),
Maria Cicognani(1) & Francesco Gritti(1).
(1)Dept. of Infectious Diseases and Immunopathology
Unit, Clinical Pathology, Maggiore Hospital, Bologna, Italy; (2)Laboratoire
d'Immunobiologie, Faculté de Médecine des Saints-Pères,
Paris, France; (3)Immunotherapy Unit, 1st Division of Urology,
Malpighi Hospital, Bologna, Italy
The efficiency of HIV-1 specific transfer factor (TF) administration,
combined with Zidovudine (ZDV), in asymptomatic persistent generalised
lymphadenopathy, or AIDS related complex (ARC) patients was evaluated.
Twenty patients were randomly assigned to receive only ZDV (1st
group) or ZDV together with HIV-1-specific TF (2nd group). HIV-1-specific
TF was administered orally at 2 x 107 cell equivalent daily for
15 days, and thereafter once a week for up to 6 months. There were
no significant differences between the two groups in clinical evolution,
red blood cells, haemoglobin, lymphocytes, CD20 subset, transaminases,
a-2-microglobulin, p24 antigen. White blood cells, CD8 lymphocytes
as well as IL-2 levels increased in the second group, while the
CD4 subset increased in the first group. The combination treatment
with ZDV and TF appeared to be safe and well tolerated. Furthermore,
levels of serum cytokines were investigated in 10 patients (8 asymptomatic
and 2 ARC) treated with ZDV, and compared with 5 patients of the
2nd group (3 asymptomatic and 2 ARC) treated with ZDV plus HIV-1-specific
TF. Peripheral lymphocytes, CD4, CD8 subsets, IL-2, TNFa, IL-6,
p24 antigen, IL-2 soluble lymphocyte receptors (sR), CD4sR, CD8sR
and a-2-microglobulin were evaluated at the baseline and at the
3rd month. The CD4 subset was not significantly different in the
two groups, whilst IL-2 increased in the 2nd group, receiving ZDV
plus TF, suggesting an activation of the Th1 secretion pattern.
****
INHIBITION OF IN VITRO HIV INFECTION BY DIALYSABLE
LEUCOCYTE EXTRACTS
C Fernandez-Ortega(1), M Dubed(2), O Ruibal(2), OL Vilarrubia(2),
JC Menéndez de San Pedro(2), L Navea(2), M Ojeda1 & MJ
Arana1.
(1)Department of Cellular Biology, Center for Biological
Research and Center for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology,
Havana, Cuba. (2)Laboratory for AIDS Research, Havana, Cuba
Dialysable Leucocyte Extract (DLE) is a low molecular weight dialysable
material of disrupted peripheral human leucocytes with widespread
effects on the immune system. We described the in vitro anti-HIV
activity of DLE as well as its three chromatographic fractions
(Fa, Fb and Fc). To determine the levels of inhibition on HIV replication
by DLE we infected MT-4 cell cultures, using the Bru viral isolate
at 0.05, 0.1, 0.5 and 1 m.o.i. Previously, MT-4 cells cultures
were treated with DLE or fractions at non-toxic concentrations.
Reverse transcriptase (RT) activity and p24 antigen were evaluated
in culture supernatants at seven days postinfection. No effect
was observed when MT-4 cells were incubated with DLE for 3 h. Whereas
inhibition of HIV production was observed when MT-4 cells were
pre-treated for a longer periods of time. DLE inhibited p24 production
and RT activity more than 50% at 0.1 m.o.i. More than 80% of inhibition
was observed for all doses of DLE tested at 0.05 m.o.i. Higher
viral doses (m.o.i. 0.5 and 1) were used to assess the antiviral
activity of DLE fractions. Fraction Fb inhibits viral production
more than 80%. Otherwise, fractions Fa and Fc did not show inhibitory
effect for any viral dose used. These results indicate that DLE
is able to modulate cell susceptibility to viral infection in vitro.
****
TRANSFER FACTOR WITH ANTI-EBV ACTIVITY AS AN ADJUVANT
THERAPY FOR NASOPHARYNGEAL CARCINOMA: A PILOT STUDY
Umapati Prasad(1), Mohd Amin bin Jalaludin(1), Pathmanathan
Rajadurai(1), Giancarlo Pizza(2), Caterina De Vinci(2), Dimitri
Viza(3) & Paul H. Levine(4)
(1)University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia;
(2)Sant'Orsola-Malpighi Hospital, Bologna, Italy; (3)CNRS URA 1294,
Laboratoire d'Immunobiologie, Faculté de Médecine
des Saints-Pères, Paris, France; (4)National Institutes
of Health, Bethesda, MD and George Washington University Cancer
Center, Washington, DC, USA
Overall survival of nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) at UICC stage
IV still remains unsatisfactory even with combination chemotherapy
(CT) and radio-therapy (RT). In view of the association of reactivation
of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) with the development and recurrence
of NPC, immunotherapy in the form of transfer factor (TF) with
specific activity against EBV (TF-B1) was suggested as an adjuvant
to a combination of CT and RT in order to improve the survival.
In the present study, 6 UICC Stage IV patients received TF-B1 and
another 6 patients matched for disease stage were given TF prepared
from peripheral blood leucocytes (TF-PBL). Results were compared
with another 18 patients matched by age, sex, and stage of disease
who received standard therapy without TF during the same period
(C group). After a median follow up of 47.5 months, the survival
for the TF-B1 group was found to be significantly better (P=3D<0.05)
than the PBL and C group. While the 8 patients with distant metastasis
(DM) not treated with TF-B1 (6 in the control and 2 in the PBL
group) died due to progressive disease (average survival being
14.3 months), both patients with DM in the TF-B1 group had complete
remission: one died of tuberculosis after surviving for 3.5 years
and another is still alive, disease free, after 4.2 years. Although
the series involved a small number of cases, the apparent effect
of adjuvant immunotherapy in the form of TF with anti-EBV activity
is of considerable interest.
****
A PRELIMINARY REPORT ON THE USE OF TRANSFER FACTOR
FOR TREATING STAGE D3 HORMONE-UNRESPONSIVE METASTATIC PROSTATE
CANCER
Giancarlo Pizza(1), Caterina De Vinci(1), Diego Cuzzocrea(1),
Domenico Menniti(1), Ernesto Aiello(1), Paolo Maver(1), Giuseppe
Corrado(1), Piero Romagnoli(1), Ennio Dragoni(1), Giuseppe LoConte(1),
Umberto Riolo(2), Aldopaolo Palareti(3), Paolo Zucchelli(4),
Vittorio Fornarola(1) & Dimitri Viza(5).
(1)Immunodiagnosis and Immunotherapy Unit 1st-Division
of Urology, (2)Pharmacy, S.Orsola-Malpighi Hospital, Bologna; (3)Department
of Statistics, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy; (4)Blood
Bank Service, Maggiore Hospital, Bologna. (5)Faculté de
Médecine des Saints-Pères, Paris, France
As conventional treatments are unsuccessful, the survival rate
of stage D3 prostate cancer patients is poor. Reports have suggested
the existence of humoral and cell-mediated immunity (CMI) against
prostate cancer tumour-associated antigens (TAA). These observations
prompted us to treat stage D3 prostate cancer patients with an
in vitro produced transfer factor (TF) able to transfer, in vitro
and in vivo, CMI against bladder and prostate TAA. Forty four patients
entered this study and received one intramuscular injection of
2-5 units of specific TF monthly. Follow-up, ranging from 1 to
9 years, showed that complete remission was achieved in 2 patients,
partial remission in 6, and no progression of metastatic disease
in 14. The median survival was 126 weeks, higher than the survival
rates reported in the literature for patients of the same stage.
****
TRANSFER FACTOR AS AN ADJUVANT TO NON-SMALL CELL LUNG
CANCER (NSCLC) THERAPY
Vladimiro Pilotti(1), Mario Mastrorilli(1), Giancarlo Pizza(2),
Caterina De Vinci(2), Luciano Busutti(3), Aldopaolo Palareti(4),
Giuseppe Gozzetti(1) & Antonino Cavallari(1)
(1)Istituto di Clinica Chirurgica II, S. Orsola-Malpighi,
Bologna, Italy; (2)Modulo di Immunoterapia Divisione di Urologia
I, (3)Divisione di Radioterapia, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi,
Bologna, Italy; (4)Dipartimento di Statistica Universita degli
Studi di Bologna, Italy
The rationale for using transfer factor (TF) in lung cancer patients
is that the possibility of improving their cell-mediated immunity
to tumour associated antigens (TAA) may improve their survival.
From Jan 1984 to Jan 1995, 99 non- small cell lung cancer (NSCLC)
resected patients were monthly treated with TF, extracted from
the lymphocytes of blood bank donors. In the same period, 257 NSCLC
resected patients were considered as non-treated controls. The
survival rates of the TF treated group appear significantly improved
both for patients in stages 3a and 3b, and patients with histological
subtype "large cell carcinoma" (P<0.02). Survival
of TF treated patients is also significantly higher (P<0.02)
for patients with lymphnode involvement (N2 disease). The results
of this study suggest that the administration of TF to NSCLC resected
patients may improve survival.
****
USE OF ANTI HHV-6 TRANSFER FACTOR FOR THE TREATMENT
OF TWO PATIENTS WITH CHRONIC FATIGUE SYNDROME: TWO CASE REPORTS
Dharam V. Ablashi1,2, Paul H Levine3,
Caterina De Vinci4, James E. Whitman, jr1 ,
Giancarlo Pizza4, & Dimitri Viza5
1Advanced Biotechnologies inc, Columbia
MD 21046 USA, 2 Dept of Microbiology & Immunology,
Georgetown University, Washington , DC 20007 USA; 3 Viral
Epidemiology , NCI, Rockville, MD 20892 USA; 4 Sant'Orsola-Malpighi
Hospital, Bologna, Italy; 5 CNRS URA 1294, Laboratoire
d'Immunobiologie, Faculté de Médecine des Saints-Pères,
Paris, France
A specific Human Herpes virus-6 (HHV-6) transfer factor (TF) preparation,
administered to two chronic fatigue syndrome patients, inhibited
the HHV-6 infection. Prior to treatment, both patients exhibited
an activated HHV-6 infection. TF treatment significantly improved
the clinical manifestations of CFS in one patient who resumed normal
duties within weeks, whereas no clinical improvement was observed
in the second patient. It is concluded that HHV-6 specific
TF may be of significant value in controlling HHV-6 infection and
related illnesses.
****
LESSONS FROM A PILOT STUDY WITH TRANSFER FACTOR IN
CHRONIC FATIGUE SYNDROME
Caterina De Vinci1, Paul H Levine2, Giancarlo
Pizza1, Hugh H. Fudenberg3, Perry
Orens4, Gary Pearson2 & Dimitri Viza5
1Sant'Orsola-Malpighi Hospital, Bologna,
Italy; 2Viral Epidemiology Branch, National Cancer Institute,
Bethesda, MD USA; 3NeuroImmunoTherapeutics Research
Foundation Spartanburg, S.C.; 4 Great Neck, New York,
NY, USA; 5CNRS URA 1294, Laboratoire d'Immunobiologie,
Faculté de Médecine des Saints-Pères, Paris,
France
Transfer factor (TF) was used in a placebo controlled pilot study
of 20 patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS). Efficacy of
the treatment was evaluated by clinical monitoring and testing
for antibodies to Epstein Barr virus (EBV) and Human Herpes
virus-6 (HHV-6). Of the 20 patients in the placebo-controlled trial,
improvement was observed in 12 patients, generally within 3-6 weeks
of beginning treatment. Herpes virus serology seldom correlated
with clinical response. This study provided experience with oral
TF, useful in designing a larger placebo-controlled clinical trial.
****
THE USE OF TRANSFER FACTORS IN CHRONIC FATIGUE SYNDROME:
PROSPECTS AND PROBLEMS
Paul H. Levine
Viral Epidemiology Branch, National Cancer Institute,
Bethesda, MD USA.
Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is a heterogeneous disorder characterized
by severe prolonged unexplained fatigue and a variety of associated
symptoms such as arthralgias, myalgias, cognitive dysfunction,
and severe sleep disturbances. Many patients initially present
with an acute onset of apparent infectious origin with either an
upper respiratory or gastrointestinal illness, fever, chills, tender
lymphadenopathy, and malaise suggestive of a flu-like illness.
In some cases, specific viral infections can be identified at the
outset, particularly herpes viruses such as Epstein-Barr virus
(EBV), human herpes virus-6 (HHV-6), and cytomegalovirus (CMV).
Transfer factor (TF) with specific activity against these herpes
viruses has been documented. With some studies suggesting that
persistent viral activity may play a role in perpetuation of CFS
symptoms, there appears to be a rationale for the use of TF in
patients with CFS and recent reports have suggested that transfer
factor may play a beneficial role in this disorder. This report
focuses on the heterogeneity of CFS, the necessity for randomized
coded studies, the importance of patient selection and sub-classification
in clinical trials, and the need to utilize specific end-points
for determining efficacy of treatment.
****
THE INFLUENCE OF AGE ON TRANSFER FACTOR TREATMENT OF
CELLULAR IMMUNODEFICIENCY, CHRONIC FATIGUE SYNDROME AND/OR CHRONIC
VIRAL INFECTIONS.
Ivo Hana(1), Jiri Vrubel(1), Jan Pekarek(2) & Karel Cech(2)
(1)Dept. of Immunology, Institute for Clinical and
Experimental Medicine; (2)Institute of Sera and Vaccines, Prague,
Czechia.
A group of 222 patients suffering from cellular immunodeficiency
(CID), frequently combined with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS)
and/or chronic viral infections by Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) and/or
cytomegalovirus (CMV), were immunologically investigated and treated
with transfer factor (TF). The age range was 17-77 years. In order
to elucidate the influence of aging on the course of the disease
and on treatment, 3 subgroups were formed: 17-43 years, 44-53 years,
and 54-77 years. Six injections of Immodin (commercial preparation
of TF by SEVAC, Prague) were given in the course of 8 weeks. When
active viral infection was present, IgG injections and vitamins
were added. Immunological investigation was performed before the
start of therapy, and subsequently according to need, but not later
than after 3 months.
The percentages of failures to improve clinical status of patients
were in the individual subgroups, respectively: 10.6%, 11.5% and
28.9%. The influence of age in increasing the low numbers of T
cells was evident: 10.6%, 21.2% and 59.6%. In individuals unaffected
by therapy, persistent absolute lymphocyte numbers below 1,200
cells were found in 23.1%, 54.5% and 89.3% in the oldest group.
Statistical analysis by Pearson's Chi-square test, and the test
for linear trend proved that the differences among the individual
age groups were significant. Neither sex, not other factors seemed
to influence the results.
The results of this pilot study show that age substantially influences
the failure rate of CID treatment using TF. In older people, it
is easier to improve the clinical condition than CID: this may
be related to the diminished number of lymphocytes, however, a
placebo effect cannot be totally excluded.
****
ORALLY ADMINISTERED HSV-SPECIFIC TRANSFER FACTOR (TF)
PREVENTS GENITAL OR LABIAL HERPES RELAPSES
Giancarlo Pizza(1), Dimitri Viza(2), Caterina De Vinci(1),
Aldopaolo Palareti(3), Diego Cuzzocrea(1), Vittorio Fornarola(1) & Roberto
Baricordi(4)
(1)Immunodiagnosis and Immunotherapy Unit, 1st-Division
of Urology, S.Orsola-Malpighi Hospital, Bologna Italy; (2)Laboratoire
d'Immunobiologie, URA 1294 CNRS, Faculté de Médecine
des Saints-Pères, Paris, France; (3)Department of Statistics,
University of Bologna, Italy; (4)Department of Genetics, University
of Ferrara, Italy
Forty-four patients, suffering from genital (22) and labial (22)
herpes were orally treated with HSV-1/2-specific transfer factor(TF).
TF was obtained by in vitro replication of a HSV-1/2-specific bovine
dialysable lymphocyte extract. Treatment was administered bi-weekly
the first 2 weeks, and then weekly for 6 months, most patients
received 2-3 courses. The total observation period for all patients
before treatment was 26660 days, with 544 relapses, and a relapse
index of 61.2, whereas the cumulative observation period during
and after treatment was 16945 days, with a total of 121 relapsing
episodes and a cumulative RI of 21.4 (P<0.0001). Results were
equally significant when the 2 groups of patients (labial and genital)
were considered separately. These observations confirm previous
results obtained with the bovine HSV-specific TF, and warrant further
studies to establish HSV-specific TF as a choice of treatment for
preventing herpes recurrences.
****
EFFECT OF ANTI-HERPES SPECIFIC TRANSFER FACTOR
J. Byston, K. Cech, J. Pekarek & J. Jilkova
Dept. of Allergology and Clinical Immunology,
Faculty Hospital, Pavlova 6, Olomouc, Czech Republic
Using a blood cell separator, lymphocytes were collected from
otherwise healthy convalescents suffering from herpetic infections.
A specific anti-herpes dialysate (AH-DLE) was prepared from the
lymphocytes, using standard procedures. Patients with recurrent
herpetic infections were treated with a single dose of the dialysate,
at the initial signs of herpetic infection (group A), in two doses
(group B) or in three doses (group C). A total number of 37 patients
(29 women, 8 men, age range 15-73 years) were treated. No improvement
was observed in 7 patients (18.9%), whilst 7 patients did not manifest
any exacerbation of their herpetic infection in the course of the
one-year follow-up. The remaining 62.2% of the patients showed
a marked improvement: decrease of the frequency and/or duration
or relapses. Before AH-DLE administration, the mean number of herpes
relapses in this group of patients was 12 p.a.. After therapy,
the number of relapses decreased to 3.5 p.a.. No statistically
significant difference was observed between groups A and B. The
least favourable results were registered in group C. However, this
group included 6 female patients extremely resistant to the previously
therapeutic attempts, including inosiplex, non-specific DLE or
acyclovir. Thus, even in this group, the therapy was successful
in 50% of the patients.
****
EFFICACY OF TRANSFER FACTOR IN TREATING PATIENTS WITH
RECURRENT OCULAR HERPES INFECTIONS
Renato Meduri(1), Emilio Campos(1), Lucia Scorolli(1), Caterina
De Vinci(2), Giancarlo Pizza(2) & Dimitri Viza(3).
(1)Eye Physiopathology Clinical Service, University
of Bologna, Italy; (2)Immunotherapy Unit, 1st Division of Urology,
Ospedale O. Malpighi, Bologna, Italy; (3)Laboratoire d'Immunobiologie,
URA 1294 CNRS, Faculté de Médecine des Saints-Pères,
Paris, France
Recurrent ocular herpes is an insoluble problem for the clinician.
As cellular immunity plays an important role in controlling herpes
relapses, and other studies have shown the efficacy of HSV-specific
transfer factor (TF) for the treatment of herpes patients, an open
clinical trial was undertaken in 134 patients (71 keratitis, 29
kerato-uveitis, 34 uveitis) suffering from recurrent ocular herpetic
infections. The mean duration of the treatment was 358 days, and
the entire follow-up period 189121 before, and 64062 days after
TF treatment. The cell-mediated immune response to the viral antigens,
evaluated by the lymphocyte stimulation test (LST) and the leucocyte
migration test (LMT) (P<0.001), was significantly increased
by the TF treatment. The total number of relapses was decreased
significantly during/after TF treatment, dropping from 832 before,
to 89 after treatment, whereas the cumulative relapse index (RI)
dropped, during the same period, from 13.2 to 4.17 (P<0.0001).
No side effects were observed. It is concluded that patients with
relapsing ocular herpes can benefit from treatment with HSV-specific
TF.
****
TRANSFER FACTOR IN CHRONIC MUCOCUTANEOUS CANDIDIASIS
Massimo Masi(1), Caterina De Vinci(2), Olavio Roberto Baricordi(3).
(1)Allergology and Clinical Immunology Center, Department
of Pediatrics, University of Bologna; (2)Experimental Urology Unit,
Division of Urology - S.Orsola-Malpighi Hospital, Bologna, Italy.
(3)Department of Genetics, University of Ferrara, Italy
Fifteen patients suffering from chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis
were treated with an in vitro produced TF specific for Candida
albicans antigens and/or with TF extracted from pooled buffy coats
of blood donors. CMI of the patients was assessed using the LMT
and the LST in presence of candidine. The aim of the study was
the clinical evaluation of TF treatment and the incidence of positive
tests before, during, and after therapy. Immunological data were
matched using the Chi square test. 87 LMT were performed for each
antigen dose and, at the dilution of 1/50, 58.9% (33/56) tests
were positive during non-treatment or non-specific TF treatment.
On the contrary 83.9% (26/31) were positive during specific TF
treatment (P<0.05). In the LST, a significant decrease of thymidine
uptake in the control cultures in presence of autologous or AB
serum was observed when patients were matched according to non-treatment,
and both non specific (P<0.05) and specific TF treatment (P<0.01).
Only during specific TF treatment was a significant increase of
reactivity against the Candida antigen at the highest concentration
noticed when compared with the period of non specific treatment
(P<0.01). Clinical observations were encouraging: all but one
patient experienced significant improvement during treatment with
specific TF. These data confirm that orally administered specific
TF, extracted from induced lymphoblastoid cell-lines, increases
the incidence of reactivity against Candida antigens in the LMT.
LST reactivity appeared not significantly increased with respect
to the periods of non treatment, but was significantly increased
when it was compared to the non-specific TF treatment periods.
At the same time, a clinical improvement was noticed.
****
USE OF TRANSFER FACTOR FOR THE TREATMENT OF RECURRENT
NON-BACTERIAL FEMALE CYSTITIS (NBRC): A PRELIMINARY REPORT
Caterina De Vinci(1), Giancarlo Pizza(1), Diego Cuzzocrea(1),
Domenico Menniti(1), Ernesto Aiello(1), Paolo Maver(1), Giuseppe
Corrado(1), Piero Romagnoli(1), Ennio Dragoni(1), Giuseppe LoConte(1),
Umberto Riolo(2), Massimo Masi(3), Giuseppe Severini(4), Vittorio
Fornarola1 & Dimitri Viza(5).
(1)Immunodiagnosis and Immunotherapy Unit, 1st-Division
of Urology, Bologna; (2)Pharmacy, S.Orsola-Malpighi Hospital, Bologna;
(3)Department of Pediatrics, S.Orsola-Malpighi Hospital, and Faculty
of Medicine, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy; (4)Division
of Urology, S.Maria delle Croci Hospital, Ravenna, Italy; (5)Laboratoire
d'Immunobiologie, URA 1294 CNRS, Faculté de Médecine
des Saints-Pères, Paris, France
Results of conventional treatment of female non-bacterial recurrent
cystitis (NBRC) are discouraging. Most patients show an unexpected
high incidence of vaginal candidiasis, while their cell mediated
immunity to Herpes simplex viruses (HSV) and Candida antigens seems
impaired, and it is known that the persistence of mucocutaneous
chronic candidiasis is, mainly, due to a selective defect of CMI
to Candida antigens.
Twenty nine women suffering of NBRC, and in whom previous treatment
with antibiotics and non-steroid anti-inflammatory drugs was unsuccessful,
underwent oral transfer factor (TF) therapy. TF specific to Candida
and/or to HSV was administered bi-weekly for the first 2 weeks,
and then once a week for the following 6 months. No side effects
were observed before treatment. The total observation period of
our cohort was 24379 days, with 353 episodes of cystitis recorded
and a cumulative relapse index (RI) of 43. The observation period
during and after treatment was 13920 days with 108 relapses and
a cumulative RI of 23 (P<0.0001). It, thus, seems that specific
TF may be capable of controlling NBRC and alleviate the symptoms.
****
SOME PROPERTIES AND PROTECTIVE ACTIVITY OF SPECIFIC
DLE AGAINST SALMONELLA CHOLERA SUIS INFECTION
Atanas Arnaudov(1), Nicola Tziporkov(2)
(1)Regional Veterinary Research Institute - Nezavisimost
boul. 111, Plovdiv 46; (2)Higer Institute of Food and Flavour Industry,
Biochemistry Dept.-Maritza boul. 26, Plovdiv 42, Bulgaria
From a rabbit lymphoid tissue, twice immunized with a Salmonella
ch. suis vaccine, it was obtained a dialysable leucocyte extract
(DLE) (m.w. 10000 Da ; protein content 1.14 mg/ml; content of ribose
2.7 mg/ml; A260/A280 ratio 2.17 and pH 6.8).
By gel filtration on Sephadex G-25, six peaks were obtained and
activity was found in peak IV. The activity of the extract was
determined by a dermo-application test (DAT) on 10 cows. The protective
effect was tested by challenge with Salmonella ch. suis and Salmonella
dublin pathogen strains on white mice intraperitoneally treated
with DLE. The DAT proved to be positive in 8 of the 10 cows. When
applied on white mice, it induced a high specific protective effect
against Salmonella ch. suis (70%), but not against Salmonella dublin
infection.
****
DIALYSABLE LYMPHOCYTE EXTRACT (DLYE) IN INFANTILE ONSET
AUTISM: A PILOT STUDY
H. H. Fudenberg
NeuroImmunoTherapeutics Research Foundation Spartanburg,
S.C., USA
40 infantile autistic patients were studied. They ranged from
6 years to 15 years of age at entry. 22 were cases of classical
infantile autism; whereas 18 lacked one or more clinical defects
associated with infantile autism ("pseudo-autism"). Of
the 22 with classic autism, 21 responded to transfer factor (TF)
treatment by gaining at least 2 points in symptoms severity score
average (SSSA); and 10 became normal in that they were main-streamed
in school and clinical characteristics were fully normalized. Of
the 18 remaining, 4 responded to TF, some to other therapies. After
cessation of TF therapy, 5 in the autistic group and 3 of the pseudo-autistic
group regressed, but they did not drop as low as baseline levels.
****
AN ATTEMPT TO INHIBIT THE COURSE OF AMYOTROPHIC LATERAL
SCLEROSIS (ALS) BY SUPPRESSOR FACTOR
Oldrich Nevsimal(1), Jan Pekarek(2) & Karel Cech(2).
(1)Neurological Clinic of the Medical Faculty, Charles's
University, Praha, Czech Republic. (2)SEVAC Ltd. Praha, Czech Republic
Forty amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) patients were treated
with suppressor factor. The therapy led to the normalization of
the immunoregulatory index in approximately two thirds of the patients.
The responder patients had a better clinical response, i.e. the
degenerative process slowed down or it was even arrested. This
favourable effect was accompanied with a significant increase in
the patients' life span. When the therapy had no effect on the
CD8 cells, it was discontinued. Stopping the therapy led to disease
progression and death; thus, in some patients, therapy was carried
out despite its failure to increase the CD8 cell numbers. Substantial
clinical improvement was noticed in these patients. The mean survival
of patients with ALS was 2-3 years, whereas ALS patients treated
with the suppressor factor survived on the average more than 5
years.
****
DIALYZABLE LYMPHOID EXTRACT (DLE) FROM MICE RESISTANT
TO STZ-INDUCED DIABETOGENESIS CAN INTERRUPT THE PROGRESS OF DIABETES
IN STZ-TREATED CD-1 MICE
Wm. Borkowsky, Robert Pilson, and H.S. Lawrence.
New York University Medical Center. Departments
of Paediatrics and Medicine, Divisions of Infectious Diseases and
Immunology, New York, NY, USA.
DLE was prepared from the minority of euglycemic CD-1 mice, previously
injected with STZ, and was administered to hyperglycemic CD-1 male
mice 1, 2 and 3 weeks after completion of multidose STZ. Mice treated
with DLE derived from 2 x 107 (1X) or 108 lymphocyte equivalents
(lymph.equ.) were significantly less hyperglycemic than the saline
treated controls (P<0.001). The effects of DLE remained evident
for more than 10 weeks after the final DLE treatment. Mice treated
with DLE prepared from diabetic mice (hg DLE) developed a somewhat
more rapid onset of hyperglycemia than the STZ treated control
animals, although this effect did not achieve statistical significance
(P=0.1). This DLE was absorbed on a rat insulinoma cell line (RIN),
which contains interspecies cross-reacting islet antigens, and
compared to the unabsorbed DLE. Mice treated with hg DLE preabsorbed
on RIN cells, showed a slower onset of hyperglycemia. DLE prepared
from euglycemia mice and the RIN-absorbed fraction were equally
capable of preventing hyperglycemia (P<0.05).
In order to determine whether the DLE effects were genetically
restricted, DLE was prepared from BALB/c mice, normally resistant
to the diabetogenic effects of multidose STZ, both before and after
STZ treatment. STZ primed CD-1 mice treated with 3 weekly doses
of 2 x 10^7 lymph. equ. of untreated BALB/c derived DLE, STZ treated
BALB/c derived DLE, and STZ treated CD-1 DLE were all less hyperglycemic
than the control mice, who received saline (P<0.001). However,
mice treated with CD-1 DLE were less hyperglycemic than the mice
given BALB/c derived DLE (P<0.05). These effects were relatively
long-lived.
Mice that were given the >3,500 Dalton fraction of CD-1 DLE
were significantly less hyperglycemic than either the control mice
or those treated with the 3,500 Dalton fraction of CD-1 DLE (P<0.05).
Effects remained evident for more than 3 months after the last
dose of DLE. Pancreatic tissue from the mice treated with the >3,500
Dalton fraction of CD-1 derived DLE revealed slightly more islets
of a slightly greater size with less surrounding inflammation than
either control mice or mice treated with the <3,500 Dalton fraction
of DLE.
****
PROFILES OF CYTOKINE PRODUCTION IN RECIPIENTS OF TRANSFER
FACTORS
Linda Alvarez-Thull and Charles H. Kirkpatrick
Innovative Therapeutics, Inc. and The Divisions
of Allergy and Clinical Immunology National Jewish Center for Immunology
and Respiratory Medicine and the University of Colorado Health
Sciences Center Denver, Colorado, USA
Transfer factors (TF) are proteins that transfer the ability to
express cell-mediated immunity from immune donors to non-immune
recipients. The mechanisms of these effects have not been defined.
The experiments described in this report were undertaken to test
the hypothesis that a mechanism through which the beneficial effects
of TF are expressed in clinical situation is through "education" of
the immune system to produce certain cytokines in response to antigenic
stimulation. BALB/c mice were sensitized to Herpes simplex virus
(HSV) either by sublethal systemic or cutaneous infections by administration
of a HSV-specific TF. One week later their spleen cells were collected
and single cell suspensions were stimulated in vitro with irradiated
HSV or concanavalin A. Culture supernatants were collected and
assayed for content of IL-2, IL-4, IL-10 and IFN-g.
Spleen cells from infected mice responded to concanavalin A and
to HSV by secreting large amounts of IL-2 and IFN-g, modest amounts
of IL-10, and no IL-4. Transfer factor recipients produced similar
cytokine profiles in response to concanavalin A. These mice, however,
responded to HSV by secreting IFN-g, but no IL-2. Thus, TF treatment
selectively affects cytokine production in response to antigenic
stimulation.
****
THE EFFECT OF DLE FRACTIONS ON GM-PROGENITORS OF HAEMATOPOIETIC
STEM CELLS IN VITRO
Barnet K., Vacek A., Cech K. & Pekerek J.
SEVAC a.s., Praha, Czech Republic
Dialysable leucocyte extracts (DLE) prepared from buffy coats
of human blood, potentiates the effect of Colony-stimulating factor
(CSF) on the growth of granulocyte-macrophage colony forming cell
(GM-CFC) colonies in vitro. This relative increase of the number
of colonies is apparent when diluted CSF (present in lung conditioning
medium) as a control, and DLE, in a wide range of concentrations
are added to the culture of mouse bone marrow cells. Fractionation
of DLE on Amicon membranes revealed that the activity resides in
molecules of 0-5kD. Molecules 5-10kD have no potentiating effect.
DLE and its fractions (0-5kD, 0-1kD), except fractions 0-500 D
and 5-10kD, when added undiluted i.e. at the initial concentration,
exerted a suppressive effect: colonies are not formed despite the
presence of CSF. In a pilot experiment, it was shown that DLE is
able to stimulate colony-forming activity of earlier progenitors
of erythroid cells (BFUe), under the influence of erythropoietin.
****
DIALYSABLE LEUCOCYTE EXTRACT (DLE) REDUCES LIPOPOLYSACCHARIDE-INDUCED
TUMOUR NECROSIS FACTOR SECRETION IN HUMAN LEUCOCYTES
Miriam Ojeda Ojeda, Celia B. Fernandez Ortega & Manuel
de J. Arana Rosanz
Department of Cell Biology, Center for Biological
Research, P.O. Box 6996, Havana, Cuba
Dialysable leucocyte extract (DLE), obtained from lysed leucocytes,
provide clinical effectiveness in a broad spectrum of diseases.
Tumour necrosis factor (TNF) is raised in AIDS patients leading
to increasing in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) replication
in vitro [1,2]. Whereas progression to AIDS in asymptomatic HIV
infected individuals is retarded under treatment with DLE. In the
present study we tested the DLE effect in vitro on both TNF biological
activity (cytotoxicity) in L929 cells and its induction by lipopolysaccharide
(LPS) in human monocytes as well as in whole blood from healthy
donors. When monocytic cells were simultaneously exposed to LPS
and DLE during a period of 5 1/2 hours, the induction of TNF was
strongly diminished. The same inhibitory effect of DLE on TNF induction
was observed when LPS was added to the culture medium prior to
DLE. No significant effect of DLE on TNF-mediated cytotoxicity,
even in the presence of the highest concentrations of DLE tested,
was detected. DLE treatment of whole human blood regulates responses
to LPS: simultaneous in vitro expose to endotoxin provokes a remarkable
decrease (4- and 1.6-fold) of TNF release. In pre-incubation experiments,
TNF production was largely reduced or completed abrogated. These
results could, in part, explain the in vivo observed effect, when
under treatment with this extract, the progression to AIDS of HIV-infected
individuals was retarded. The results suggest that 'natural' substances
like DLE may be important immunomodulators in inflammatory diseases.
****
INFLUENCE OF A DLE-EXTRACTED LYMPHOCYTIC SUPPRESSOR
FACTOR ON CSA-INDUCED IMMUNOSUPPRESSION
V.E.M. Rosso di San Secondo, A. Aniasi, G. Piccolo, P.C. Montecucchi & G.Sirchia
Transplantation Immunology and Blood Transfusion
Center, University-Hospital Policlinico, Via F.Sforza 35, 20122
Milano, Italy
From dialysable leucocyte extracts (DLE) we have purified a hydrophilic
low-mol. wt. factor (about 1 kDa) which we have named lymphocytic
suppressor factor (LSF) as it is able to suppress antigen- and
mitogen-induced lymphocyte transformation and to prolong allograft
survival in C57b/6N mice (H-2b) transplanted with fully mismatched
skin from C3H/HeN mice (H-2k). At the molecular level LSF acts
by inhibiting DNA replicational and transcriptional processes in
activated lymphocytes, isolated rat hepatocyte nuclei, and cell-free
systems. Amino acid analysis indicates that LSF is a peptide composed
of Asp, Glu, Ser, Thr, Ala, Gly, Arg and probably Met, with the
N-terminus blocked, possibly by pyroglutamic acid. When combined "in
vitro" with cyclosporine A (CsA), LSF increased about 20 times
the potency of CsA in inducing suppression of mitogen-stimulated
lymphocytes. In C57b/6N mice with skin graft from C3H/HeN mice
and undergoing immunosuppression with CsA (50 mg/kg/day), the splenocyte
LSF content increased about 5 times. However, LSF values returned
to normal in mice recovering normal responsiveness due to progressive
withdrawal of CsA. These data show that LSF has an important role
in the development and maintenance of CsA-induced immunosuppression.
We suggest that, by influencing DNA replicational and transcriptional
processes of lymphocytes, LSF may play a role also in the onset
and progression of retro-viral diseases including AIDS.
****
IN VITRO STUDIES DURING LONG TERM ORAL ADMINISTRATION
OF SPECIFIC TRANSFER FACTOR.
Giancarlo Pizza(1), Caterina De Vinci(1), Vittorio Fornarola(1),
Aldopaolo Palareti(2), Olavio Baricordi(3) & Dimitri Viza(4).
(1)Immunodiagnosis and Immunotherapy Unit 1st-Division
of Urology, S. Orsola Malpighi Hospital, Bologna, Italy; (2)Department
of Statistics, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy;(3)Department
of Genetics, University of Ferrara, Ferrara Italy; (4)URA 1294
CNRS, Laboratoire d'Immunobiologie, Faculté de Médecine
des Saints-Pères, Paris, France
153 patients suffering from recurrent pathologies, i.e. viral
infections (keratitis, keratouveitis, genital and labial herpes)
uveitis, cystitis, and candidiasis were treated with in vitro produced
transfer factor (TF) specific for HSV-1/2, CMV and Candida albicans.
The cell-mediated immunity of seropositive patients to HSV-1/2
and/or CMV viruses was assessed using the leucocyte migration inhibition
test (LMT) and lymphocyte stimulation test (LST) in presence of
the corresponding antigens, and the frequency of positive tests
before, during and after TF administration was studied. The data
were stratified per type of test, antigen and the recipients' pathology,
and statistically evaluated. For the LMT, a total of 960 tests
were carried out for each antigen dilution, 3 different antigen
dilutions were used per test. 240/960 tests (25.4%) were found
positive during non-treatment or treatment with unspecific TF,
whereas 147/346 tests (42.5%) were found positive when the antigen
corresponding to the specificity of the TF administered to the
patient was used (P<0.001). When the data were stratified following
pathology, a significant increased incidence of positive tests
during specific treatment was also observed (0.0001<P<0.05).
In the LST (1174 tests), a significant increase of thymidine uptake
was observed in the absence of antigen (control cultures), during
treatment with both specific and unspecific TF, but also in the
presence of antigen and/or autologous serum during specific TF
administration (P<0.0001). TF administration also significantly
increased the soluble HLA class I antigens level, in 40 patients
studied to this effect.
|