Selective Abstracts from the XIth International
Symposium on Transfer Factor
Universidad Autonoma de Nuevo Leon, Monterey,
Mexico
March 1-4, 1999 |
Transfer Factor As A Therapeutic Agent In Moderate
And Severe Atopic Dermatitis
D. Navarro-Cruz**, E. Serrano-Miranda*, M. Orea-S**, S.
Estrada-Parra*, L. Terán-Ortiz, J. Gomez-Vera And
G. Flores-Sandoval*
* Department Of Immunology, Encb, Ipn.** "Lic. Adolfo
Lóópez Mateos Hospital Issste, Mexico City
The current knowledge of Transfer Factor (TF) actions as
led immune response modulator has lead us to investigate its
usefulness in-patients with atopic dermatitis. These patients
that are unresponsive to the conventional therapy, show a cellular
immune deficiency so that we believe possible to obtain a clinical
improvement with the use of TF. We did a prospective, comparative,
experimental study with 30 patients with moderate to severe
atopic dermatitis (AD). Laboratory examination was performed
in all patients: complete blood cell count, IgA, GM and E determination,
lymphocyte subpopulations CD3, CD4, CD8, CD4/CD8 ratio, CD25,
rosette formation for B and T Lymphocytes, coproparasitoscopic
examination, throat and nose cultures, nasal cytology, skin
test of cellular immunity to PPD, thrichophytin, candidine,
varidasa, skin prick test to pollens, fungi, inhalants and
foods. All patients underwent a sign and symptoms grading score
system as follows: the parameters were erythema, pruritus,
eczema, papules scored on a scale form 4+ to 0:0= no symptoms,
+ mild, ++= Moderate, +++= Severe, ++++= Very Severe. Initially
all patients received one placebo unit every 15 days orally
3 times, then one after 30 days. Laboratory examination was
performed and then treatment with transfer factor was initiated,
1 unit every 15 days three times and the fourth 30 days after.
15 days after the last dose a new immunological evaluation
was done. Results showed a decrease in CD4, eosinophils and
IgE, although not statistically significant. There was a statistically
significant improvement in the 4 clinical parameters: erythema,
eczema, pruritus and papules.
Treatment Of Atopic Dermatitis With Transfer Factor
And Cyclosporin A
M. A. Cordero-Miranda**, E. Serrano-Miranda*1, G.
Flores-Sandoval**, J. Gómez-Vera**, M. Orea-S**, B.
Correa-Meza*, R. Ramírez*, A. Badillo-Flores* And
S. Estrada-Parra**
Department Of Immunology, Encb, Ipn.** "Lic. Adolfo
López Mateos Hospital"/ Issste, Mexico City
Atopic dermatitis (AD) is a chronic skin disease that appears
in patients with a personal or family history of allergic asthma
and rhinitis. It is associated to the specific activation of
a gene group. In most instances, the response to the conventional
treatment is adequate. There are cases, though, known as refractory,
where that is not the case. The study of two therapeutic alternatives,
Transfer Factor (TF) and Cyclosporin A (CyA), was elaborated
for this type of patients. AD patients were randomly divided
in two groups. The first one was subjected to TF, as follows:
one unit (U) every third day for the first week, 2U/week for
the next three weeks and 1U/monthly to complete six months.
Initial and final clinical and immunological testing was performed
on both groups (eosinophils (EO), total IgE, CD4 and CD8).
Six patients were included in group A and 12 in B. Both groups
showed a significant statistical reduction in the total EO
counts, without a statistical difference between them. None
showed changes in total IgE levels. CyA reduced the CD4 counts,
while TF increased the CD8 ones. Both with a p 0.05. Both groups
showed clinical improvement statistical significant, but no
difference between them were observed. Tolerance to the treatment
was adequate, and there was no need to suspend the treatment
in any case. Only three patients showed therapeutic benefits
in the treatment of patients with severe refractory AD, with
similar immunological improvement. Both drugs have different
mechanisms of action, so their joint application probably could
offer clinical benefits to the patients (synergistic action),
cost reduction, and long-term treatment with reduced adverse
effects.
Successful Treatment Of Posherpetica Neuritis (Caused
By Herpes Zoster) With Specific Transfer Factor
R. Ondarza, R. Chávez, E. Serrano, B. Correa, R.
Ramírez, I Estrada-G, And Sergio Estrada-Parra
Department Of Immunology, E.N.C.B, The National Polythenic
Institute, Mexico City
Neuritis posherpetica is one of the most important complications
associated with Herpes zoster infection. It is characterized
by intense pain that prevents patients from carrying out their
normal activities. Our group has successfully treated a large
number of Herpes zoster patients (together with the Cuban group
more than 2,000) with specific Transfer Factor. We are now
presenting the results of treating one of the Herpes zoster
complications for which there has been no effective treatment
available. The Transfer Factor was obtained from the Blood
Bank, form healthy donors who as children has varicella (chickenpox).
A group of 40 patients diagnosed with Neuritis Posherpetica
were treated with Transfer factor (TF). The ages of patients
varied from 32 to 65 years of age. The time of previous evolution
of the infection was from 75 days to 7 years.
All patients have been previously treated with antiviral
agents (90% with acyclovir), analgesics, vitamin B12 and carbamazepine
(70% of the cases). The patients studied were selected for
the presence of persistent neurosis. Before the study a "profile
of cellular immune response" was performed and the common
denominator was found to be a reduction in the percentage of
T lymphocytes measured by rosette formation. The value of this
immunological parameter was below normal values. The same was
found for the intradermal reactions to PPD, candida, tricophytin
and varidase. The treatment scheme with TF was 1 unit daily
for 5 days, then 2 units a week (for 1 month), then 1 unit
a week (for 1 month), in some of the patients the treatment
was improvement in symptoms was noted for all patients. For
ethical considerations treatment with carbamazepin and analgesics
was continued in some of the patients. It may be concluded
from this first study that TF is a valuable resource for the
treatment and prognosis of this type of chronic ailment.
Suppurative Adenopathy By Salmonella B Treated
With Transfer Factor
A Case Report
R. Berron, PhD., C. Almendarez, M.D., G. Rosiles, M.D.
National Institute Of Pediatrics, Mexico City
A 6 year old, male, native from Toluca (Mexico), with past
family history a dead brother 6 years old, with the same clinical
characteristics. The patients main complain were: intermittent
fever, giant adenopathies cervical, and then acquired fistulous
section and purulent drainage of these adenopathies lasting
two years of evolution. The patient received treatment for
tuberculosis without response. One year later the patient was
hospitalized again at the National Institute of Pediatrics
(Mexico) with chicken pox and exacerbation of the symptoms.
Laboratory examination showed that haematological & usual
urine, hepatic and renal functional tests were normal. Immunoglobulins,
Complement and phagocytosis test and NBT reduction were normal.
The febrile reactions reported: Tiphy 0=1:400, Paratiphy B=1:800,
Paratiphy A=1:320. Specific antibodies for Salmonella B=1:320,000.
The Cultures of Blood, feces and secretion of the cervical
adenopathies were positive for Salmonella B. The Ziehl Nielssen
in urine and secretion of the adenopathies were negative. The
Ganglion Biopsy report: Lymphoreticular hyperplasia. With this
clinical and laboratory picture a treatment with antibiotics
was started and continued for ten days. However, the symptomatology
continued, and the decision to begin "unspecific" Transfer
Factor was taken, with partial response; later the administration
of Specific Transfer Factor obtained through the immunization
of a patients uncle, a complete remission of the symptoms
was observed.
A defect in the cellular specific immunity was hypothesised,
supported by the exacerbation of the symptoms with concomitant
varicella manifestation. The initial decision was to start
unspecific transfer factor and then because of the persistence
of the symptoms, the pathogen specific transfer factor was
given with the complete remission of the symptomatology, without
relapsing after ten years of follow-up. This case can be considered
as a defect in the specific cellular immunity for the Salmonella
B antigens, because the patient showed a good response for
other pathogens. We propose that a cellular defect in the differentiation
of the T helper lymphocyte exists with a decreased TH1, that
is critical for the production of IL2 and IFN gamma. In this
patient, the excellent response observed with specific transfer
factor supports this hypothesis.
Biological And Clinical Testing Of Swine Transfer
Factor For Oral Administration (Imunorr)
Vlastimil Kral, Josef Richter, Jan Lastovicka, Marie Zehnulova,
Dalibor Jilek, Ladislava Panajotovova.
Institute Of Public Health, Ustil N.L., Czech Rep. Res. Inst.
Pharmacy And Biochemistry, Prague, Czech Rep.
Dept. of Immunology of the Public Health Inst. has been
involved in oral immunomodulation since the 80«s. In the years
1987-1988 laboratory reparation of swine transfer factor (TF)
was started and later (1992-1993) a preclinical and pilot study
of clinical testing of swine transfer factor for oral use was
carried out. One unit of TF is dialyzable extract from 5x108 peripheral
blood leukocytes from a veterinary examined swine without any
vaccination. Preclinical biological testing of TF was done
on an inbred strains mouse model in several systems. The most
important ones were: 1.- ex vivo/in vitro system: of experimentally
immunosuppression (induced by Azathioprine) and following restoring
effect of TF on in vitro mitogenic (PHA, ConA, LPS, PWM) proliferation
of CD3, 4, 8 expression on peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL),
2.- in vitro: proliferation of PBL induced with suboptimum
ConA conc. (testing of constimulatory activity of TFp.o.),
3.- in vivo system: the host resistance against tumor growth
(mouse leukemia cell line L1210). In all the above mentioned
systems swine TF was compared with standard human TF preparation
for injection (IMMODINR, Sevac, a.s., Prague). The general
outcome of these tests was that oral TF showed equal or even
slightly better significant influence on examined parameters
when it was used in 5 times the dose used for injection. This
result corresponds with published data.
A pilot clinical trial: 37 patients characterized predominantly
by secondary immunodeficiency state, were treated only with
oral TF for 6-10 weeks (one unit per weekly). The laboratory
tests for T cell immunity parameters were done before and after
treatment. It was shown a significant improvement of the several
laboratory parameters (e.g. increase of CD3 and CD4 lymphocytes,
active ERFC) ; significant clinical benefit was achieved when
parameters of T cell immunity were decreased before treatment.
Transfer Factor (Immodin Sevac) Treatment Of Recurrent
Anterior Uveitis.
A Retrospective Evaluation After 10 Years.
I. Hána*(1,2), J. Stara (3), J. Boguszaková (3),
J. Pekárek (4), E. Ivasková (1).
(1) Dept. Of Immunology, Institute For Clinical And Experimental
Medicine; (2) Postgraduate Medical School; (3) Dept. Of Ophthalmology,
First Medical School, Charles University; (4) Sevafarm; Prague,
Czechia.
Since 1987 an attempt to treat recurrent anterior uveitis
by long-term application of transfer factor has been undertaken
with the goal to reduce or possibly totally eliminate recurrent
attack of this eye disease. Altogether, 50 patients at several
time points have been enrolled into the study who, prior to
the start of the transfer factor therapy, had had several attacks
of uveitis per year, usually three or more. A commercial preparation
of human transfer factor (Immodin SEVAC, Prague, Czechia) was
used, applied normally at three months intervals by subcutaneous
injection. The patients were subject to regular check-up at
the Ophthalmology Dept. of the University Hospital: frequencies
of recurrences of uveitis were recorded and compared to frequencies
prior to the start of the treatment. The duration of treatment
ranged from 35 to 85 months, the observation period was extended
to 4 years after the therapy was completed; the longest observation
period was more than 10 years. The final evaluation was based
on hospital records and on simultaneous questioning the patients.
Only a part of the 50 patients were lost from the final evaluation
due to change of address or death.
The Transfer Factor treatment produced remarkably good results
since of the 36 evaluated patients more than 70% experienced
no typical recurrence at all. In about 25% of these patients
some very slight eye discomfort was noted, (no more than 3-5
days of duration), that couldn't be compared to the severity
of preceding attacks. Typical recurrences, usually in sporadic
numbers, were observed in only a few patients who obviously
did not respond well to the therapy. In conclusion, vast majority
of the evaluated patients have been relieved from recurrent
and severe attacks of uveitis even in the period after the
application of the transfer factor had been finished.
Fifteen Years Of Clinical Use Of Dle-Immodin In Czech
Rep.
Jan Pekarek*, Karel Cech, Karel Barnet.
Department Of Immunomodulators, Sevapharma Ltd., Praha 10,
Czech Republic
At our institute the research of TF-DLE started in 1967.
At first we prepared and tested in laboratory experiments specific
transfer factors. Biological activities of DEL from human and
animal leukocytes (blood and lymphatic organs, bovine colostrum)
were tested. Various methods of DLE preparation (disintegration
of cells, ultrafiltration, dialysis) were tested as well. The
low M.W. fraction is now produced by dialysis, ultrafiltration,
pasteurized for 10 hours at 60¡C and freeze-dried. Large clinical
screening on more than 1.000 patients in 1982 was performed.
Since then, more than 300.000 doses have been administered
for therapeutic purposes. Some data on biological activities
we have tested as well as a list of clinical effects attained
with this preparation during its 15 years application are presented.
Efficacy Of Transfer Factor In Severely Infected
Pediatric Patients
Ayala-De La Cruz M.C (1) , Rodríguez-Padilla C.
(2) And Tamez-Guerra, R (2).
(1) Inmunoalergías Y Laboratorio De Patología,
Hospital De Especialidades No. 25 Instituto Mexicano Del Seguro
Social, Monterrey, Nuevo León Mexico (2) Laboratorio
De Inmunología Y Virología, Facultad De Ciencias
Biológicas, Universidad Autónoma De Nuevo León,
San Nicolas De Los Garza, Nuevo León, Mexico
Patients. This is a retrospective study of 45 patients treated
from 1986 to 1998. These children were 3 to 16 years of age
with an average of 4.2 years, severely infective and non-responsive
to conventional treatment. Some had multiple infections. Twenty
eight were girls, and 17 boys. They had: pneumonia (32 cases),
gastrointestinal infections (8), repetitive urinary tract infections
(12), vulvovaginitis (3), skin infections (11), herpes simplex
I and II (5), osteomyelitis (1), undetermined fevers (8), malnutrition
grade III (2), IgA deficiency (5), and IgG deficiency (1).
Methods. The patients were evaluated when they had already
received conventional medication and their serological studies
were available along with appropriate skin tests. The blood
and serologic studies included: RBC sedimentation, C reactive
protein, antistreptolysinase, febrile reactions, IgA, IgE,
IgG & IgM, C3 & C4 components of complement, T&B
lymphocytes, inhibition factor for lymphocytes migration to
different antigens like candida, varidase, PPD & coccidiomycoides.
However, their response rapidly worsened. The quantification
of T lymphocytes was carried out and the percent of defective
cells computed. The number of doses of the transfer factor
programmed depended on this percentage. It was applied i.m.
at 3-24 months. Control studies of the treatment were conducted.
The clinical response was highly satisfactory, and all cases
except 2 reached remission. These 2 cases had congenital deficiency
IgA and IgG continuing with respiratory and digestive problems,
but with improved performance.
Conclusion. We consider that the use of the transfer factor
in these patients was a most useful application that allowed
clinical and serological improvements, abated infections, shortened
hospitalisation, and improved the quality of life.
The Transfer Factor In The Management Of A Case
Of Encephalitis Caused By Coccidioides Immitis. A Case
Report.
Ayala-De La Cruz M.C (1) , Rodríguez-Padilla C.
(2) And Tamez-Guerra, R (2).
(1) Inmunoalergías Y Laboratorio De Patología,
Hospital De Especialidades No. 25 Instituto Mexicano Del Seguro
Social, Monterrey, Nuevo León Mexico (2) Laboratorio
De Inmunología Y Virología, Facultad De Ciencias
Biológicas, Universidad Autónoma De Nuevo León,
San Nicolas De Los Garza, Nuevo León, Mexico
This Case was a boy of 5 from Gomez Palacio, Durango with
clinical meningitis. Cerebrospinal fluid cultures were positive
for Coccidioides immitis. The condition was treated
for 112 days with iv and intratecal Amphotericin B and Fluconazol
without favorable response. A ventriculoperitoneal tube for
hydrocephalia was installed without neurological improvement.
T lymphocytes were at 32% with control at 50%. Migration inhibition
and intradermal tests were negative for coccidioidin.
A regime of 29 doses of transfer factor i.m. gave satisfactory
clinical results with remission of the neurological problem,
disappearance of fever, T cell increase to 58% with 64% for
the control. MIF to coccidioidin continued negative and the
intradermal reaction to cocci produced only erythema. CFS became
negative. The patient resumed normal activities.
Comment. The specific cellular defect in this patient with
coccidiomycosis was established by quantification of T lymphocytes.
There was a defect of 36% with absence of intardermal response
to coccidioidin with MIF 0. Following the lack to response
to conventional therapy, specific transfer factor permitted
clinical improvement. However, in laboratory tests, the patient
did not become positive for either test with coccidioidin.
Management Of Hypereosinophilia With Transfer Factor
Ayala-De La Cruz M.C (1) , Rodríguez-Padilla C.
(2) And Tamez-Guerra, R (2).
(1) Inmunoalergías Y Laboratorio De Patología,
Hospital De Especialidades No. 25 Instituto Mexicano Del Seguro
Social, Monterrey, Nuevo León Mexico (2) Laboratorio
De Inmunología Y Virología, Facultad De Ciencias
Biológicas, Universidad Autónoma De Nuevo León,
San Nicolas De Los Garza, Nuevo León, Mexico
The patient was a girl of 2 from Cd. Frontera, Coahuila,
hospitalised following high temperature ( up to 38.5¡C ) for
6 months with general malaise, loss of 2 kg, non-responsive
generalized dermatitis classified as scabies, and basal pneumonia.
Paraclinical studies showed 6.5 g hemoglobin, hypochromia,
anisocytosis, leukocytosis to 55900, 87% eosinophilia with
48633 eosinophils, 2900 IU IgE, 2130 mg% IgG, 38% T lymphocytes
with control at 54% and 17% B lymphocytes.
The patient was studied under the protocol of hypereosinophilic
syndrome, dismissing hypotheses such as neoplasms or parasitoses.
Twenty-seven doses of transfer factor were used to manage this
defective cellular immunity. Satisfactory recovery included
normal growth, normal temperature, remission of skin lesions,
normal coloration of membranes, adequate haemoglobin at 12.1
g, drop in leukocytosis to 7700 with eosinophils at 1309, and
IgE dropped to 452 IU. The patient became asymptomatic.
Comment. This patient had a cellular defect shown by T cell
counts at 30% defective. At the time the study was carried
out TH1/TH2 was not assessed, although it would have helped
in establishing the imbalance. However, we think that there
was a TH2 defect that generated the eosinophilia and hyper
IgE. This defect was controlled by the administration of transfer
factor.
Use Of Transfer Factor In A Case Of Refractive
Urinary Tract Infection
Ayala-De La Cruz M.C (1) , Rodríguez-Padilla C.
(2) And Tamez-Guerra, R (2).
(1) Inmunoalergías Y Laboratorio De Patología,
Hospital De Especialidades No. 25 Instituto Mexicano Del Seguro
Social, Monterrey, Nuevo León Mexico (2) Laboratorio
De Inmunología Y Virología, Facultad De Ciencias
Biológicas, Universidad Autónoma De Nuevo León,
San Nicolas De Los Garza, Nuevo León, Mexico
This patient was a girl of 5 with persistent urinary tract
infections from 5 months of age with malaise and fever whose
urocultures were positive for Escherichia coli. Growth
retardation included 8.3 kg & 88 cm at 1 year, 10 months,
and 10.0 kg and 88 cm at 2 years, 10 months. Radiologically,
there was a reflux of vesicoureter II. T lymphocytes were 9%
of a control at 48% defective at 81.5%. by the migratory inhibition
test for varidase, was negative and with PPD at 10%. A total
of 82 doses of transfer factor were applied im. At the 6th
dose, urocultures were negative. At the final treatment, T
lymphocytes were at 43% as the normal reading was with the
migratory test for varidase 25% and for PPD 33%. Later she
had a urethral reimplant with satisfactory results. A year
later she had negative urocultures no fever and good body growth.
Experience With Transfer Factor in 60 ICU Patients.
Galan-Guajardo S. (1) And Rodríguez-Padilla C (2).
(1) Hospital Oca, (2) Laboratorio De Inmunología Y
Virología, Facultad De Ciencias Biológicas, Universidad
Autónoma De Nuevo León
We present preliminary clinical data using Transfer Factor
in 60 ICU patients. Patients were divided in two groups: Group
A- Patients hospitalized but not critically ill, and Group
B- Patients in ICU. Our study is observational, since for many
patients it was impossible for us to perform an experimental
double blind prospective study.
Criteria were: -Patients with immunodeficiencies and diabetic
patients unresponsive to conventional therapy.
Although at the beginning of the study we intended to determine
several cytological and immunological parameters, obtention
of data was too slow to be useful for clinical decisions. In
all cases, 1 vial of Transfer Factor was used 3 times a day
for 3 days via oral, IM and IV, depending on patient and physician
preference.
Results. In all cases, there was a clinical improvement
, impossible to obtain otherwise. We also noticed a better
resistance of the patients to surgery, fewer complications,
etc. As a consequence, there was a reduction in the hospitalization
time.
Conclusion. This is not a controlled study, but our observations
suggest the possibility of clinical use of Transfer Factor
in the type of patients we studied. We believe that a controlled
clinical trial should show the usefulness of Transfer Factor
in critically ill patients.
TF, Psoriasis And Cytokines
Wang Yuying, Liu Zhenxiang, Shen Li.
Department Of Dermatology, 3rd College Of Clinical Medicine,
Beijing Medical University, China
Psoriasis is characterized in histopathology by infiltration
of leukocytes, hyper-proliferation of epidermal keratinocytes
and the shorten cell renewing process. More and more, in the
studies of psoriasis, the results have showed that cytokine
system possessed important role in the network of inflammatory
pathogenesis. It might be significant to inhibit the synthesis
of specific cytokines or block the combination of activation
of those receptors in therapeutics. Therefore, we started the
clinical observation on 38 psoriasis patients with the treatment
of Oral Transfer Factor (OTF) and the basic study on the mRNA
expression of related cytokines (IL-8, IFNr, TNF:ç) within
the skin lesions before and after the treatment.
The results indicate that skin inflammation was improved
and the mRNA expression of IL-8, IFNr and TNF were reduced
obviously. Furthermore, this suggests the role that such cytokines
may play in the pathogenesis and therapy of psoriasis.
Clinical Study Of P-TFOL Liquid Treating Hepatitis
Wu Jingxing, Jiang Jia Kun.
Beijing Medical University, China
PURPOSE: To evaluate the therapeutic effectiveness of P-TFOL
produced by Jiang Xi Gannan Pharmaceutical Factory in treating
hepatitis B.
METHODS: 25 hepatitis B patients have been studied
ages 16-67 (mean 39.2), hepatitis B history1~20 years (mean
6.48), 17 of them are men. Every patient drinks P-TFOL 10 mg
(10ml) per day for 3 months. Liver and kidney function, serological
and virological test have been done before and after treatment.
RESULTS:
(1) P-TFOL can improve some symptoms. (2) It can decrease
serum transaminoferase in 56% patients, but albumin and bilirubin
can not be changed. (3) It can affect hepatitis B virus (HBV)
serology, HBsAg disappeared in 1 of 25 patients, 2 HBV-DNA
became negative in 14 patients with both HBeAg and HBV-DNA
positive, one HBeAg became negative, HBV-DNA became negative
in 8/9 (88%) with both HBeAg-negative and HBV-DNA positive
patients, ALT decrease in the same time. (4) It can prominently
improve T-cell subtypes, CD4 became normal in 84% (11/13) and
CD4/CD8 ratio increase in 61% patients. (5) In all patients,
P-TFOL has therapeutic effectiveness in 52% patients, 3 of
them are prominent and 12 of them are invalid. All these results
suggest that P-TFOL can play a role in regulation of immunological
system, it can improve hepatitis B patientsÕ immunological
function, protect liver and inhibit HBV replication. It is
worth being used as an adjuvant treatment of hepatitis B.
Observation Of 26 Senile Cases Treated With P-Tfol
Wang Huifang, Zhou Guanghua, Yu Zhiying, Xu Yonggang,
Jiang Jia Kun.
Beijing Medical University, China
At present, the study of senility shows there are lots of
harmful factors in the body that can result in senility. Researchers
also found that the decrepit of the immunity function is one
of the most obvious features of senility and it shows itself
mainly in the decrepit of the cell immunity. The help/inducer
T cell and cytotoxic/suppressor T cell take important roles
in the adjustment of response to immunization in body. We use
random sampling method to observe the T lymphocyte subpopulation
of 26 aged people who take the P-Transfer Factor Oral Liquid
(P-TFOL) produced by Jiang Xi Ganna Pharmaceutical Factory.
Three months they took the P-TFOL, the CD8 decreased. Processed
by statistics, our results prove to be meaningful.
Therapeutic Trial Of Antigen-Specific Transfer
Factors In The Chronic Fatigue Immune Dysregulation Syndrome:
Evidence Of Latent Virus
H.H. Fudenberg, M.D.
The NeuroImmunoTherapeutics Foundation
Inman, SC 29349
Antien-specific Transfer Factors (ASTFs) were used serially
in blind "placebo" controlled crossover study of
40 patients with Chronic Fatigue Immune Dysregulation Syndrome
(CFIDS), so severely ill that they were unable to work for
2-10 years and unable to leave their house or even their room.
Of the 40 patients, clinical improvement occurred in 32 with
one of the five ASTFs, generally within 3-6 weeks of
beginning therapy and was dramatic at 3 months. Antigen-selective
defects in Cell-Mediated Immunity (CMI) to one or another virus
corresponded with clinical response to the relevant TF but
not to control TF (HHV1-TF). Some patients with defective CMI
for CMV did not respond to HHV6-TF but responded to CMV-TF,
and some with CFIDS due to the Rubella vaccine virus (5pts)
responded neither to HHV6-TF, CMV-TF, nor EBV-TF but responded
to the Rubella virus vaccine-TF. Two additional patients with
past histories of severe hepatitis B, completely recovered
by 1 ½-2 years prior to the onset of symptoms of CFIDS,
did not respond to any of the three ASTFs used in the other
patients, but did respond to ASTFs specific for Hepatitis
B. In general antibody titers to the organism to which the
TF was effective showed an inverse correlation with CMI.
Opportunities For Clinical Trials With Transfer
Factor
Paul H. Levine, M.D. And Gary Simon, M.D.
Viral Epidemiology Branch Rockville, Md USA
It is important to have an agreement as to the criteria
for developing clinical studies with transfer factor (TF) and
to
discuss how best to document effectiveness of specific preparations.
Despite the publication of numerous reports demonstrating the
efficacy of TF in a variety of disorders, the scientific community
remains skeptical in regard to its potential in clinical medicine.
A series of collaborative studies with Drs. Dimitri Viza and
Giancarlo Pizza have shown that effective TF produced in vitro
and replicated in standardized reproducible batches can be
safely used in clinical trials. Therefore, the possibility
for replicating studies with TF in multiple centers is now
an achievable goal that can lead to greater acceptability of
this material in absence of complete biochemical characterization.
Several
criteria are needed for the initiation of clinical trials:
1) The problem should be an important medical issue; 2) There
should be the opportunity for short-term objective documentation
of effectiveness of the TF; 3) The study should be placebo
controlled and double blind. We suggest initiating studies
involving treatment of specific infectious agents where their
control can be readily documented by collaborating laboratories.
Among the most important current medical problems involving
infectious agents are the following: 1) human herpes virus-induced
Kaposi's sarcoma; 2) Epstein-Barr virus-induced malignancies,
including AIDS-related central nervous system lymphoma, nasopharyngeal
carcinoma and Burkitt's lymphoma; 3) cytomegalovirus-induced
retinitis, and 4) human herpesvirus-6 pneumonia and encephalitis
in immunosuppressed individuals. In spite of the changing pattern
of HIV infection in developed countries with effective use
of drug therapy, the complications remain a problem in developing
countries as well as in individuals everywhere who develop
drug intolerance or drug resistance. We will propose the details
of possible multi-center trials of transfer factor with proven
and documented effectiveness which will determine whether or
not they can be effective in the treatment of the important
clinical problems.
The Effect Of Transfer Factor On The Synthesis
Of Human Cytokines
M. Pérez-Tapia, S. Rivera-Gutiérrez, A Pérez-Barrera,
B. Correa-Meza, R. Ramírez-Ruiz, L. Sntos Argumedo**,
I. Estrada-G*1 And S. Estrada-Parra*1.
Department Of Immunology, E.N.C.B, The National Polythenic
Institute, Mexico City
Because TF contains approximately 200 different substances,
fundamental information concerning its characteristics, such
as the mechanisms of its activity, has been generated at a
slow peace.
In this work, we show the development of an in vitro method
for the evaluation of the effects of TF preparations, which
were prepared at our school. 2x105 peripheral blood mononuclear
cells (PBMC) were taken from healthy donors, then seeded in
96 well U-bottomed plates and stimulated in triplicate with
TF, either concentrated or diluted 1:10 and 1:100. As an activation
control ConA (10 ug/ml) was used and all the cultures were
incubated for 6 h. Following incubation the cells were resuspended
in lysis buffer. Subsequently, mRNA was analyzed by the RT-PCCR
technique, using primers for B-actin, IFNy, RANTES, TNFx, IL-2
and osteopontin (OPN). The results show that only OPN mRNA
is completely blocked in cells treated with TF, in a dose dependent
manner.
Using ELISA kits we proved the capacity of TF to induce
IL-8 and RANTES IN TF activated PBMC as well as in PMBC activated
with supernatants derived from TF activated cells. We also
investigated whether TF itself contains cytokines. None of
the cases studied produced IL-8. A weak production of RANTES
was observed in the PBMC cultures activated with supernatant
derived from TF has a direct effect on PBMC and that indirectly
may induce the synthesis of RANTES.
Dialyzable Lymphocyte Extracts Modify Soluble-Hla
And Serum Lymphokine Levels
D.Viza (1), G.Pizza (2), C. De Vinci (2), O. Baricordi
(3), A. Palareti (4).
(1) Laboratoire D'Immunobiologie, Faculté De Médicine,
Paris, France (2) Immunotherapy Unit, 1st Division Of Urology,
Malpighi Hospital, Bologna, Italy (3) Department Of Genetics,
University Of Ferrara, Ferrara, Italy (4) Department Of Computer
Sciences, University Of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
Rationale. Soluble HLA class I antigens (sHLA) levels markedly
increase during the course of viral infections, and we have
shown that TF treatment also increases their serum level as
it does that of certain lymphokines viz. IL-2 and IL-6. Thus,
we have further investigated the variation of sHLA, in patients
receiving TF treatment.
Methods. 41 patients suffering from recurrent ocular pathologies
(keratitis, keratouvetitis, uveitis), were treated with LDV/7-produced-TF
specific for HSV-1/2, CMV and EBV. Serum samples were collected
and the sHLA level was determined by ELISA. In several of these
patients the serum levels of MIF, RANTES, IL-4, IL-12, IL-15,
and gamma-IFN were also tested.
Results. TF administration significantly increased the sHLA
level in 25/41 patients (P<0.008). (Seven patients had an
increase of >2SD and 14 of >1SD of the average range).
Furthermore it was noticed a significant increase of MIF
(P<0.03) and a near to significance one for IL-12 (P<0.09),
gamma-IFN and Rantes. A significant decrease was observed for
IL-15 (P>0.05) and a not significant one for IL-4. A statistical
treatment of the data observed (Pearson correlations) suggests
a direct correlation between HLAs and IL_12 (P<0.026), IL-4
and gamma-IFN (P<0.001) and an inverse correlation between
IL-4 AND IL-12 (P<0.030) or Rantes (P<0.01). Also an
inverse correlation was observed for gamma-IFN and MIF (P<0.01)
or IL12 (P<0.0001). With a non-parametric evaluation (Spearman
rank order correlations) a direct positive correlation between
MIF and gamma-IFN (P<0.05) was also found.
Conclusion. Although preliminary, the present data clearly
show the ability of DEL to modify HLAs and cytokines patterns
in the patient's serum. The significance of these observations
remains at present unclear. Nonetheless, they do confirm that
the observed clinical activity of the TF administration is
not due to a placebo effect but it is rather mediated by a
complex interplay between cytokines and effector cells.
Cytokine And Lymphocyte Levels In Extrinsic Asthma
Patients Treated With Transfer Factor
J. A. Enciso (1), E. Serrano Miranda (1), J. C. Gómez-Martinez
(2), A.Portuguez-Diaz (2), A. Badillo, M.Orea-S (2), J. Gómez-Vera
(2), G. Flores-Sandoval (2) And S. Estrada-Parra (1).
(1) Uimep, Cmn Siglo Xxi, Imss. (2) Hosp. "Adolfo López
Mateos", Issste, E.N.C.B, The National Polythecnic Institute,
Mexico City
In Bronchial extrinsic asthma inflammation has an important
role in pathogenesis. We have measured cytokines and lymphocytes
in patients with bronchial extrinsic asthma before and after
treatment with Transfer Factor (TF).
Placebo (P) and TF were given to all patients for a six
period each. During the treatment, cough, wheezing and sputum
were clinically evaluated, as well as lymphocyte subpopulations,
the later by flow cytometry. Cytokines were measured by ELISA.
CD4 lymphocytes were slightly increased before treatment,
and remained so after P treatment. CD8, CD2 and B lymphocytes
were within normal ranges, and did not show changes after TF
treatment. On the other hand eosinophil counts decreased after
TF treatment. TNF-a, IL-6, IL-8 and IL-10 were evaluated. We
did not find TNF-a in patients sera, IL-6 levels were slightly
increased (p=0.052); IL-8 levels were also increased, and did
not show any changes after treatment (p=0.02). There were no
changes in IL-10 levels. Regarding the clinical symptoms there
were impressive results: coughing was reduced in 25% with P
treatment vs. 60% with TF, wheezing was reduced by 30% with
P treatment Vs. 80% with TF and sputum secretion was decreased
only by 30% in P treated patients vs. 80% with TF.
Patients under TF showed clear clinical improvement (69.6%),
but only had minor changes in lymphocyte sub-populations and
cytokine levels.
Enhancing Effect Of Transfer Factors On Granulocyte-Macrophage
Colony Forming Units Of Immune-Mediated Aplastic Anemia In
Vitro
V.E. Ferrer, F. Masso, J.J. Montesinos, E. Miranda, L.
Hernández And B. Ortiz .
General Hospital Mexico And National Autonomous University
Of Mexico, Mexico City
The effect of transfer factors (TF) on colony forming units
(CFU-C) of peripheral blood cells from patients with immune-mediated
aplastic anemia (IMAA) was studied in vitro. TF were prepared
following Lawerence's technique from leuko-concentrates of
normalblood donors. Mononuclear cells form patients were incubated
with or without TF in RPMI medium at a 5:1 ratio of TF: patients’ lymphocytes
at 37° C with a CO2 flow of 5%. Normal controls with and
without TF were also incubated. The cells were then
cultured in soft agar for 14 days. Besides, normal cells were
cultured with the supernatants from the patient's cells. The cells
of the patients incubated with TF showed a fifteen-fold increase
in the numbers of CFU-c compared with those incubated without
TF. Normal controls showed no changes with or without TF. However,
when added the supernatants of the incubated cells of the aplastic
patients, there was a significant decrease in the number of
CFU-c (up to 10-fold). The decrease was much less striking
with the supernatants of the aplastic patients incubated with
TF. These results support the hypothesis that TF might correct
the suppression of hemopoiesis in IMAA.
DLE Increase Stimulatory Effect Of Cytokines On
Hematopoiesis
K. Barnet, Vacek A., Cech K., Pekárek J., Schneiderová H.
Department Of Immunomodulators, Sevapharma Ltd., Praha 10,
Czech
Dialyzable extract of human leukocytes (DLE-Transfer f.
IMMODIN SEVAC) belongs to BRM enhancing in vitro the effect
of cytokines on differentiation and proliferation of progenitors
of granulocyte and macrophage colony forming cells (GM-CFC)
of the mouse BM. A single DLE injection to mice after sublethal
gamma irradiation increased the recovery of GM progenitors
as compared with controls and this stimulatory effect of DLE
was further enhanced by repeated injections. Serum of mice
treated with DLE has no CS activity in vitro but potentiates
the effect of mouse CST as well as human rhu G-CSF on the growth
of GM colonies from GM-CFC in mouse BM. Therapy with irradiated
mice with rhu G-CSF enhanced the recovery of damaged progenitors
in BM. Combined therapy of rhu-G-CSF and DEL elevated further
this recovery. This therapy is now tested in patients with
severe neutropenia.
Transfer Factor For Cell-Mediated Immune Response
Rehabilitation Activities In Irradiated Mice
E.G. Goleva, T.A. Lyubchenko, D.M. Grodzinski*, L.S. Kholodna.
Faculty Of Biology Dept. Of Microbiology And Immunology,
Ukraine
The purpose of this investigation was to study the activity
of TF preparations on the effect of radiation at doses that
do not change hematopoiesis. Mice of Balb/c line were used.
The animals were irradiated in doses of 0,5 and 2 Gy. TF preparations
were studied for their: a) biochemical properties (presence
of aminoacids, proteins, saccharides, nucleotides, nucleic
acids); b) pharmacological characteristics (pyrogenity, toxicity,
sterility, presence of HIV and hepatitis antigens, mutagenic
effects); c) immunological properties (Migration Inhibition
Factor production, Interferon, Interleukins 1 and 2, Tumour
Necrosis Factor, IgG and IgM antibody production, rosettes
forming tests, phagocytosis, influence on differentiation of
bone marrow cells precursors, blast transformation activity,
delayed type hypersensitivity). The obtained results may be
considered as a proof of the immunostimulating properties of
TF. That provides evidence for the use of TF in the treatment
of ecological immunodeficiencies. Transfer Factor had positive
effects in rehabilitation of immune system of irradiated mice.
It was shown by normalization of the immunological parameters
and increase of resistance to Staphylococcus aureus after TF
administration to irradiated animals. We think that it may
be due to direct influence of TF on differentiation of bone
marrow cells precursors, T-mitogenic effects by means of stimulating
cytokine production, and ability to modify T-cell receptor
and activate membrane processes involving Ca2+ messengers.
Functional Activity Of Lymphocytes In Rats With
Radiation Induced Hypothyreosis After Xenotransplantation Of
Thyroid Gland Organ Culture And Immunostimulation With Transfer
Factor
E.G, Goleva., Lyubchenko T.A., Pasteur I.P.,*, Kholodna
L.S., Gorban E.N.*, Donich S.F.*, Tronko M.D.*
Faculty Of Biology Dept. Of Microbiology And Immunology, Ukraine
The purpose of this investigation was to study the functional
activity of lymphocytes from rats with radiation-induced hypothyreosis
after xenotransplantation of newborn pig thyroid gland organ
culture and the immunostimulating influence of transfer factor
(purified and fractionated dialyzable leukocyte extract). Such
transplantation didn't reduce immune activity of rat's splenocytes
in vitro. Preparations of human and animal transfer factor
activated thymidine incorporation into splenocyte's DNA, enhanced
activity of macrophages and their antigen-presenting functions
in intact animals as well as in rats with thyroid gland xenotransplant.
There was also group of rats with irradiated thyroid gland,
which function was substituted by injections. In this group
we observed reducing of lymphocytes functional activity, which
was successfully corrected by transfer factor. We concluded
that xenotransplantation of thyroid gland organ culture didn't
reduce immune activity of recipient's splenocytes and macrophages.
Transfer factor can be used as a stimulator for immunodeficiency
caused by thyroid gland dysfunctions.
Dialyzable Leukocyte Extract (Dle) Suppresses
Transcription Factor Nf-Kb Activity In Unstimulated Mt-4 Cells
Ojeda, M., Fernández-Ortega, C. and M.J. Arana
Cell Biology Division, Center For Biological Research,
La Habana, Cuba.
Dialyzable Leukocyte Extract (DLE) derived from immune lymphocytes
is capable of transferring specific immunity to naive T-cells.
Clinical effectiveness of this biological extract has been
demonstrated in a broad spectrum of diseases. Others have used
DLE in AIDS patients and we observed a remarkable response
in asymptomatic Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)-infected
individuals treated with DLE. Among the cellular transcription
factors, NF-Kb plays a key role in the control of transcription
of HIV, through the interaction with specific element from
the long terminal repeat (LTR). In this work we examined the
effect of DLE on NF-kB activation by EMSA, in cells that are
commonly used to study HIV replication. The T-lymphocyte cell
line MT-4 was exposed to several doses of DLE (0, 1.25 and
2.5 U/ml) during seven days, and nuclear extracts were prepared
after 0, 3h, 3 and 7 days of treatment. Under these experimental
conditions, we observed a remarkable inhibitory effect on NF-kB
activity by DLE treatment. Reduction of DNA-protein complex
formation was directly related with increments in DLE dose.
Surprisingly, DLE at 2,5 U/ml completely suppressed NF-kB activation
after seven days of MT-$ treatment. This effect is time related
with the inhibition of HIV replication observed after DLE treatment
in the same system, as we previously report. NF-kB is critical
for proper immune function, cell growth and survival. Control
of transcription by NF-kB represents a potential regulatory
step of HIV gene expression. Our data indicate that DLE has
the remarkable ability of inhibiting NF-kB DNA-binding activity.
These results significantly contribute to our knowledge of
the mechanisms responsible for the effectiveness of DLE therapy
in asymptomatic HIV patients.
Inhibition Of TNF Alpha And TGF Beta1 In Mt-4 Cells
Treated With Transfer Factor
Fernández-Ortega, C. (1); Ojeda-Ojeda, M. (1) Alcocer,
J.M. (2) Javier, F. (2); Rodriguez-Padilla, C. (2); Tamez
Guerra, R. (2) And Arana Rosainz, M. (1).
(1) Center Of Genetic Engineering And Biotechnology, La Habana
Cuba. (2) Laboratory Of Immunology And Virology, School Of
Biological Sciences, Uanl, Monterrey, Mexico
In 1954 Lawrence used the term Transfer Factor (TF) for
a dialyzable extract of sensitized leukocytes, which transfers
reactivity from skin test-positive donors to skin test-negative
recipients. The immune system is regulated by a complex network
of pleiotropic and redundant cytokines, which are continually
secreted to a greater or lesser degree even then the system
is apparently quiescent. Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)
directly infects cells of the immune system and triggers a
robust immune response, which is an important and persistent
source of immune activation. This activation is intimately
linked to cytokine secretion. Numerous cytokines induce HIV
expression, others suppress it, whereas others induce or suppress
HIV expression, depending on the culture system used. Previously,
our group reported that HIV production in MT-4 cells is inhibited
after several days of treatment with TF. In this study, we
evaluate gene expression of different cytokines on this cell
line treated
with TF. We showed that Transfer Factor inhibits the TNF alpha
and TGF beta1 gene expression. IL-2 and IL-10 gene expression
could not be observed in these culture conditions. It has been
reported that TNFalpha induces HIV expression whereas TGFbeta1
increases or reduces it depending on the cell system used,
Our results indicate that the inhibition of HIV production
in MT4 cells by Transfer Factor could be in relation with the
inhibition of the TNFalpha and TGFbeta1 gene expression by
Transfer Factor in MT4 cells. These results may be relevant
to the treatment of diseases where TNF and/or TGF plays a pathogenic
role.
Decrease In Serum HIV RNA Following Treatment With
A Leukocyte Dialysate Subfraction (Lds) That Contains N-Terminal
Peptides Of The Enkephalins And Enhances Cell Mediated Immunity
A.A. Gottlieb, C.H. Kern, H. Park, and M.S. Gottlieb.
Tulane University And Endeavor Corp.
We have previously reported that a specific sub-fraction
of human leukocyte dialysates affects cell-mediated immunity
as demonstrated by augmentation and acceleration of delayed
type hypersensitivity, enhancement of the expression of CD25
(the p55 component of the receptor for Interleukin-2) on CD4+
cells, and dose dependent biphasic enhancement of gamma-interferon
production in response to mitogen. These effects appear to
derive from the action of two peptides, Tyr-Gly and Tyr-Gly-Gly,
which are structurally identical to the N-terminal end of the
enkephalin neuropeptides.
Clinical testing of LDS in a double-blind randomized placebo
controlled trial in HIV infected patients who were anergic
and symptomatic, on entry, demonstrated a five-fold reduction
in risk of progression to AIDS compared to placebo over six
months of treatment. In patients with Rheumatoid Arthritis
who had active disease and diminished proliferative responses
to PHA, administration of LDS resulted in two-fold or greater
augmentation of proliferative responses.
In a study of sera of a subset of patients with HIV disease
from the above clinical trial matched on CD4+cell numbers at
baseline (treated mean=299 cells/mm3, placebo mean =303 cells/mm3
) we observed a 30% reduction in mean viral load over the course
of the study in patients receiving LDS and a 239% increase
in the mean number of viral copies in serum from patients who
received placebo. Five of seven patients who received LDS showed
a mean decrease in the HIV-RNA load of 50% (two patients showed
a mean increase of 22%); five of the patients who received
placebo showed a mean increase in HIV-RNA load of 370% (two
showed a mean decrease in viral load of 89%). All LDS treated
patients had a terminal decrease in viral load. LDS treated
patients had a smaller decrease in CD4+ cell number than those
who received placebo.
We believe these observations are supportive of the link
between the neuroendocrine and immune systems and may help
explain their role in modifying exacerbation and progression
of the aforementioned disease states.
Transfer Factor's Role In Signal Transduction
N.P, Fadeenko*, Davidovska T.L.*, Lyubchenko T.A.,
Goleva E.G., Kholodna L.S., Shuba M.F.*
Faculty Of Biology Dept. Of Microbiology And Immunology, Ukraine
Transfer Factor (TF) is capable to transfer and induce antigen
specific cell-mediated immune response. In our previous studies
it was shown that human and animal TF preparations to Staphylococcus
aureus antigen substances posses immunomodulating properties.
The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate the mode
of action on the membrane level. TF to St. Aureus corpuscular
antigen influences on contraction of T.Coli guinea pig cell
membrane with stable k+ polarization was investigated by means
of a tensiometric method in an isometric system. It was found
that TF had dose-response stimulating effects on contracting
component of k+ membrane. The amplitude and the time of contraction
increased by means of TF. It was concluded that TF has a modulating effect on Ca2+channels. It stimulates the Ca2+ transport into the cell. It is known that Ca2+ is one of the basic cell messengers that activates cell processes and can lead to cell differentiation and production of bioactive substances. It is one of the possible ways of activation of the immune response.
Peptide Sequences That Are Common To Transfer Factors
Charles H. Kirkpatrick, M.D.
Cytokine Sciences, Denver Colorado, U.S.A.
The structures of molecules with transfer factor activity
are unknown. Our attempts to sequence highly purified, intact
transfer factor molecules were unsuccessful, presumably because
the amino termini were blocked. Peptides prepared by glu-C
digestion of purified transfer factors produced maps that suggested
both highly conserved regions and variable regions that were
similar to other antigen binding molecules.
Transfer factors that were specific for territin, ovalbumin
or Herpes simplex glyco-protein D were prepared in mice and
cattle and purified by affinityfor antigen and hplc. These
molecules were digested overnight with cyanogen bromide and
the cleavage fragments were sequenced. Two peptides. MxLLYAQDLEDN
and MxLLYAQDVEDN were consistently obtained.
Synthetic peptides with the sequence LLYAQDLEDN did not
sensitize mice to express delayed type hypersensitivity. Both
peptides inhibited expression of delayed hypersensitivity by
transfer factor-treated mice; LLYAQDLEDN was about 100x more
potent than LLYAQDVEDN. Neither peptide inhibited expression
of delayed type hypersensitivity in actively sensitized mice.
The data are consistent with a model in which the peptides
are competing with transfer factors for a common site (receptor?)
on the target cells for transfer factors.
Supported by a Research Agreement with EntreMed, Inc.